Ocean Pals · Rays in Their World · Grades 9–12 · Page 1 of 3

Read the evidence

Name:

Two sources with different purposes

A. Species account. NOAA identifies commercial fishing as a main threat to giant manta rays. Some are caught deliberately; others are bycatch, caught while fishers seek other species. Their global population size is unknown. This is a species-specific threat assessment, not a claim about all rays.

B. Distribution research. A NOAA research summary describes more than 5,000 verified sightings gathered from surveys and other reports. Records were concentrated where people were more likely to see mantas. Researchers accounted for aerial survey effort and viewing conditions in a model of likely occurrence in eastern U.S. and Gulf waters. For example, the model predicts high nearshore occurrence off northeastern Florida in April. Sightings can include repeat observations; they are not a count of distinct animals. A regional prediction is not a global population estimate.

Terms: a distribution model uses observations and other information to estimate where an animal is likely to occur. Survey effort describes how much searching was done. A prediction is a model's expectation, not a promise of a sighting. Accounting for uneven observations improves a model; it does not remove every uncertainty.

A — NOAA Fisheries: Giant Manta Ray. B — NOAA Fisheries: Where Giant Manta Rays Go and Why (2022).

Annotate and question

Underline a threat, circle a prediction and mark an uncertainty in the briefs. How could uneven searching affect a map made from sightings? What did the researchers do about it?

What species, place and time would a claim about “vanishing rays” need to identify?

Grades 9–12 · Page 2 of 3

Build an evidence ledger

A ledger records a claim, its source, the kind of evidence and a limit. Read the worked row. Complete the next two using A or B and a category: documented threat, model prediction or stated uncertainty.

ClaimSourceCategoryLimit
Fishing threatens giant manta rays.A · NOAADocumented threatNot an assessment of every ray species.
High nearshore occurrence off northeastern Florida in April is predicted.
The global giant manta population size is unknown.

Check an inference

Does “more than 5,000 verified sightings” establish more than 5,000 different living mantas? Explain.

Set your exhibit claim

Write one supported sentence and another naming a limit or unanswered question. Identify A or B as the source.

Grades 9–12 · Page 3 of 3

Make and test a visual argument

Sketch an exhibit panel about giant manta rays. Include a documented threat from A, a regional prediction from B, one unknown and source credits. Label the study region and the distinction between evidence categories. A clear draft is enough.

Peer check

Ask a partner: which claim is documented, which is modeled, and what remains unknown? Could the image imply that the claim applies to all rays?

Revise and explain

What did you change, and how did it make your claim more accurate?